Advancing Collective Rights and Livelihoods: A Baseline Assessment of Enabling Policy Conditions in Six Countries

Author: Rights and Resources Initiative, The University of Notre Dame's Keough School of Global Affairs

Date: November 17, 2026

Since 2002, more than 250 million hectares of forests have moved into owned by or designated for Indigenous Peoples, Afro-descendant Peoples, and local communities.

But secure rights alone do not guarantee thriving livelihoods. A community may have recognized rights to its territory but still lack access to infrastructure, finance, skills, responsive institutions, or the ability to exercise its own governance systems.

Until now, there has been no common global evidence base to assess and compare these broader conditions. Developed by the Rights and Resources Initiative (RRI), the University of Notre Dame’s Keough School of Global Affairs, and a global rightsholder steering committee, this baseline addresses this gap by examining five interconnected conditions that make collective livelihoods possible: tenure security; institutional autonomy and accountability; livelihood development and capacity building; infrastructure and connectivity; and inclusive governance and cultural respect.

The baseline provides a new way to identify gaps in the laws, policies, institutions, and conditions that shape collective livelihoods. Drawing on evidence from six countries—Brazil, the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Indonesia, Nepal and Peru—the baseline illuminates the real conditions for collective livelihoods, which is the very first step towards changing them.

As climate action and investment take shape, this evidence can help inform advocacy, policy dialogue, and collective action to ensure communities can exercise their rights and pursue their own development aspirations.

The report is available in four parts:


https://doi.org/10.53892/ATRL1536
  • Key Findings

Key Findings

  1. Recognition does not guarantee implementation. All six countries analyzed recognize collective land or forest rights in law. But significant gaps remain in the institutions, capacities, and protections needed to exercise those rights. Making rights meaningful therefore requires more than just legal recognition.
  2. Capacity development is a major gap. Access to sustained adult education and vocational training is among the weakest enabling conditions identified by the study. Across the six countries, key informants’ localized estimates for this indicator ranged from 1.1 to 6.3 percent, compared with reference levels of 54 to 71 percent in the five countries where national reference levels were established. These findings point to opportunities to strengthen sustained learning and technical support for community livelihoods.
  3. Governance, accountability, and security matter. Political participation, institutional accountability, and freedom from violent conflict remain significant challenges across the countries studied. These conditions are fundamental to communities’ ability to exercise their rights and build resilient livelihoods. Enabling community economies therefore requires more than access to markets and finance.